| Fan
Discussion:
Is there life after death?
The
following is a transcript of a discussion that took place on the
Official Storm Constantine Message Board over the course of a
few days in January 2004. After a couple days, it was decided
the discussion was something that would be nice to share -- especially
if we could get some of the spelling and punctuation fixed up!
(For the original discussion, completely unedited, click here.)
Discussion
participants included (name used in transcript, followed by
full name, if known):
- Mykael
(Mykael Frances)
- Angelo
(Angelo Ventura)
- Gabby
(Gabriel Strange)
- Wendy
(Wendy Darling)
- Jess
(Jess Lenham)
- Pellaz
(Paul Cashman)
- Charapa
- Dreaming
Dervish (Kate Lawrence)
If
you'd like to keep the discussion going, go
to the original thread and hit Reply!
|
Mykael

|
Does
anyone believe in life after death? It's just that I find
it hard to believe in life after birth sometimes. Is life
just natures way of keeping meat fresh? Or is there more
than this? What do Storm fan really think? |
| Angelo

|
Our
consciousness will survive in a quantum-wave probability pattern
induced in the space-time fabric by our thoughts and our feelings.
That pattern will eventually reincarnate or flow towards a
more exalted state of being... depending on his conduct on
Earth. So anal-retentive extreme right-wingers should reincarnate
as dog's intestinal parasites. |
|
Gabby

|
Were
just meat bi-products. |
| Angelo

|
What
makes you think so? We have no proof there isn't life after
death. I prefer to keep my options open. |
|
Wendy

|
Even
when I used to go to church every week, I never bought into
the notion of "life everlasting" too much. My
basic attitude, and it's one that hasn't changed that much,
even now that I dropped church years ago, is WHY CARE?
I've
thought about the various possibilities and considering
the nature of life energy (esp. after I studied Reiki),
but even so, fretting over it or having debates seems a
waste of time. I mean, I'm just going to keep on doing what
I'm doing and I can't know (or not know, if
there isn't life after death) until there's nothing I can
do about it. I leave options open, since there's obviously
a very mysterious, yet unseen, universe out there. Seems
rather pompous & silly to deny it and somehow claim
that to be empirical and think "logically there can't
be life once the physical organism is 'dead'." |
| Angelo

|
Well
said,Wendy! Why deny the possibility? In the meantime, let's
live our present life. Happy new year! |
|
Jess

|
Er
yeah -- kinda what she said points to Wendy.
I don't think about it much. I'm pretty
sure that if reincarnation does happen we won't be
aware of it, so it really makes no difference.
|
| Angelo

|
So
you don't believe in the tales of persons narrating their
past experiences? Do you think they are all fakes? And I who
wanted to be a Wraeththu in my next life!
Seriously, I think we can't entirely dismiss
the possibility. There is something beyond physical reality,
even if we haven't got an idea of what it is. Have you ever
watched your own room from another dimension? Have you ever
felt the sensation of not being " all there"?
Have you ever felt that your guardian angel is here near
you? It's all in our brain, you can say. But what if our
brain has somewhat caught some whiff of "Otherness"?
|
|
Jess

|
I'm
not sure if I think they are fakes or not. I don't like to
judge but I'm skeptical, and I think under hypnosis the subject
is very suggestible and I think there are a lot of
unscrupulous people out there who just make people think
they had a past life experience.
I'm hardly ever "all here" cos
I'm a dopey moo most of the time, but I don't think there
is anything in that!
I am very skeptical about religious
people who claim they have been "touched by jesus"
and what have you. I've been there. I was young and vulnerable,
and when you are in a room filled with euphoria its very
easy to get carried away, I remember being sure I
had just been visited by the Holy Spirit. Went all warm
and felt completely euphoric. In those mass evangelical
gatherings they sometimes have in the US and Africa -- if
you don't know what I'm talking about, they fill a stadium
with people and have a preacher and a choir, etc., etc.
-- they often claim to heal people, people speak in tongues
and every one feels touched by Christ. It's a mass hypnotism.
The incessant talking by the preacher, the excitement of
people near you and the chanting of the choir and the music
hypnotizes everyone. And that's science. They've proved
it. FREAKY!
The only really out-of-body feelings I've
had have been drug-related (mostly legal drugs!),
as I've had lots of general anesthetics and a bad reaction
to a opiate-based painkiller (apparently I'm quite sensitive
to opiates, he he) where I really tripped out. Quite frankly
I didn't enjoy any of the experiences and wouldn't want
to have an out-of-body type experience by choice!
|
| Angelo

|
There's
something in which I agree with you. Man is suggestionable,
gullible, and skepticism is sacrosanct to ward off individuals
who want to cheat and take advantage of you.
But
sincere religious sentiment is innate in mankind. Pour example,
when I went to school run by Catholic priests. I enjoyed
religious meetings whit my classmates and chanting and feeling
brothers in Jesus. That's communion of spirits, not brainwashing,
as you can call those oceanic reunions of famigerate charlatans
like Moon or L. Ron Hubbard.
Communion
of spirits needs genuine sentiments, sincere love and/or
friendship and intimacy. And when friendly spirits commune
in contemplation of a religious entity, the God/Goddess,
Jesus, or Isis or who you have it, is there. The divine
lies within you, in your interior goodness and force. You
haven't got to go out of your mind to perceive it. Quite
the contrary. |
|
Mykael

|
I
always find it strange that it’s the questions that
can’t be answered that get the most answers.
I find the “Why Care?” answer is the one I use
the most, but there are times when the dark tea time of
the soul (d. Adams) comes creeping around (mostly about
three in the morning, when I’ve been trying to get
to sleep for hours but am still laying awake in bed) when
I start thinking "Why are we here?", "Is
there a point to all this?", "Are there spirits
watching us?", "When I die, is all that I know
and am lost forever?"
But I find life has a way of getting in the way of me finding
out (too busy living day to day to worry about death). So
my answer is "I’ll have to wait and see!"
But
I do believe that we all think and wonder about it at some
time in our lives, if it's worth thinking about it or not
is another mater! |
| Wendy

|
I
agree with you, Angelo.
Until a few years ago, I consider most kinds
of religious or spiritual experiences people described to
be bullshit, because people were just faking themselves
into thinking it. However, after I became more open-minded
to experiences and began doing energy work, I could understand
the reality of those experiences.
I don't have much interest in Christianity
or any other organized religion, because such systems don't
work for me, but I believe they use the same energy, so
people can heal one another and experience invisible power
based on their faith. Even if such experiences are taking
place in a system which I might not value too much b/c it's
repressive, rigid, narrow-minded, it doesn't mean there
isn't honest value in it.
Even now, when I occasionally visit a church
(Methodist, Catholic, whatever), I don't connect with the
beliefs, but I can connect with the singing and tell there
in is fact a spirit living among the congregation. It's
that camaderie/brothership you speak of, that sentiment
of "We are human, we are alive, we have hopes, please
be kind to us, spirits of the world."
|
|
Jess

|
I
don't agree with organized religion either. I think it creates
too much hatred and misunderstanding in this world. I think
to an outsider that "togetherness" of a congregation
of any faith can be intimidating and scary because if you
don't believe, it can look terribly like brainwashing.
I think if I found a belief system that
I was happy with I might follow it.
What I don't like is that feeling of being
a slave to a certain being. Having to follow every thing
exactly for fear of being outcast when your time comes.
Somehow that just doesn't seem the right way to live to
me. I think that you should have the strength to believe
in your own morals and choices. If a deity existed that
helped me in that and not force me into a particular way
of seeing things, then I might be convinced.
I also treasure my uniqueness of thought
-- I want the freedom to be able to form opinions of my
own about things. I don't want some organizationtelling
me that being gay is wrong or being a woman prevents you
from holding certain offices etc (those are just two examples
from Christianity). We should have the freedom to be ourselves
-- I guess that's what I dislike about many religions.
|
| Gabby

|
Big
kids with exclusive gangs, that's all organized religions
is. Ruling by fear and oppression. |
|
Jess

|
Yep!
how do you think the Church owned so much land for so many
years? They deliberately kept the Bible in latin so that the
masses couldn't read it. The read all the readings in Latin
and then "interpreted" it. Lied to the people is
what they did! |
| Angelo

|
Jess,
I'm all with you on this! |
|
Wendy

|
While
I don't have a problem with the "exclusive gangs"
bit or argue about churches' bad behavior past and present,
especially the duping and control of their own members, I
would like to say that it's important not to dis or dismiss
organized religion out of hand.
Although I don't have any interest in church,
the church I grew up attending was very good at certain
things -- chiefly teaching tolerance and understanding for
fellow human beings and inspiring people to try their best
to be good people and do good things on earth. Hell, my
own minister told me there wasn't a hell, so how bad was
that?! He said that all that talk about Heaven and Hell
was something devised to make people live in fear and feel
bad about themselves, but that in the end, everybody would
go to the same place and be embraced by God.
(Did I mention that I have quite warped
view of Methodism, based on this sort of liberalism of the
church I attended? And that this
church is "reconciling and welcoming" to gays
and supports the Massachusetts Supreme Court ruling on gay
marriage?)
Anyway, I've trashed religion many times
myself and absolute loath religious conservatives and their
aims to foist their beliefs on the public via government
and law, but I would say, there has to be tolerance
well and acknowledgement that they are not completely "broken."
|
| Gabby

|
The
question still remains, where would we be without organized
religion.
-
WWII probably would not have happened.
-
9/11 would not have happened.
-
The Crusades would not have happened.
- The
Great Plague of London would not have happened.
- The
Dark Ages would not have happened.
-
Dubya would probably not be in power.
Just
trying to think of any good things organized religion has
brought to the world. |
|
Wendy

|
Well,
during the Dark Ages Christian monks and Muslims preserved
the cultural heritage of the West at a time when most of Europe
was illiterate... that is a good thing.
I won't get into this argument, I liked
the death one better. Your list seems to me silly because
you could keep going back and back to a time w/o organized
religion and you'd wind up thousands of years ago. Everything
in history is inextricably tied together and you can't take
out one element without it affecting the whole, so saying
"without organized religion" such and such wouldn't
have happened... It doesn't work really.
|
| Mykael

|
Man
made God in his own image and then was surprised to find
that other men from a cross the sea did the same thing!
How
dare they! For we all know that Jesus was a white guy from
Oxford! How dare they make up the same stuff as we did tell
the same stories, and have the same beliefs as us and then
call it something different with different names!
My point is that we should look at the humans not their
gods, gods just get in the way. We are all born, and we
all die they, the two biggest points to life, what we do
in the time in between is down to us, not any religion or
faith and killing someone else b/c of their religion or
faith is just beyond me!
Death
is not the answer
But it is the question
Living
is the thing we tend to do while we are waiting for something
interesting to happen! |
|
Jess

|
Well
said. I think the fact that Jesus changes color depending
on where in the world you are is very telling. Facts don't
seem to matter much -- it's what he symbolizes and much of
the West couldn't cope with having their Messiah as a black
man. (cos, obviously he was white... the only white
man in the whole of the Middle East at that time, but
white nonetheless [sarcasm]). Have you seen Dogma? Brilliant
film. God as Allanis Morrissete is hard to cope with, but
I like the idea of portraying god as a woman for a change.
|
| Pellaz |
Hmmm,
I'm a recovering Catholic, myself :) I made some mental discoveries
when I was around 13, and my dad basically gave me my religious
"emancipation" -- ever since, I've basically been
agnostic (or if cornered by a rabid mob, a Deist).
Wendy, I agree with you; while it's easy
for us "enlightened" souls to point and laugh
at all the ills that organized religion is responsible for
(and they are many), it has brought some good things, too.
If attending a church, synagogue or temple keeps a child
(or an adult) from getting into trouble, then that's a small
victory. As you mentioned, the preservation of culture by
the clerics during the Dark Ages is a larger one.
There are many different paths to follow;
if the ultimate end -- basically, the Golden Rule, "Do
unto others..." -- is the same, who are we to say which
path is the sole correct one? Indeed, if the end result
is right, are any of the paths provably wrong?
As for life after death, I find it hard
to get excited about it. "Who cares?" sums up
my feelings, too. I don't need an afterlife or a reincarnation
to goad me into trying to do my best, or being nice to other
people; to me it just comes with the job description.
|
|
Mykael

|
Why
is it that we, as a race (the violent, talking monkey),
think we are so important that there has to be more for,
and to, us than what we already are? Are we all so dissatisfied
with our life’s that we have to have something else
to look forward to? Have to be more supernatural then just
being alive?!
Let's face facts. We are not the strongest animals on this
planet. We are not the most intelligent (you only have to
come down to Southend on a Saturday night to see that).
But we are the most destructive and violent (our history
is soaked in blood and pain).
Is it because life it so easy to end that we are always
looking for more? It’s like looking for life else
where in the universe, do you really think that if there
is "more intelligent" life out there that they
want us to find them? And if they are anything like us,
do we want to find them?
What
if we are all there is? Just think of it for a sec', what
if we are the most intelligent life in the universe and
there is no god, no life after death, no ghosts or spirits,
no aliens wanting to make contact, and every religion on
the planet is wrong and the life on this planet is the only
life there is anywhere? Would that make us, as a race, come
together or would it pull us apart even more?
I
know I started this thread but maybe it should have been
about do you believe in life before death, not after? |
| Mykael

|
I
find it some what telling that no-one here has said anything
about Heaven & Hell.
Are
these view of everlasting life out dated now?! Or are we
all too cool now days to believe in them?
One
thing is for sure, "no-one is getting out of here alive."
(Can't remember who said that, "Jim," I think.) |
|
Jess

|
I think the concept of Hell was pretty much invented by the
Church to keep the masses under control -- it's not really
mentioned explicitly in the Bible (although Heaven is, I think).
Someone correct me if I'm wrong, I'm not a Biblical scholar
myself, so I might've picked up that bit of information from
somewhere other than the Bible itself!
I think just the idea of not getting
into Heaven was supposed to be enough of a motivation to
follow Christ -- unfortunately it didn't really work that
way so they invented Hell.
|
| Wendy

|
When
I was going through the preparatory classes for confirmation
in my church, my minister encouraged me and everyone in
the group to ask questions about our religion, which was
a liberal form of Methodism.
I'm
not sure how I phrased it, but my question was about Hell
and whether it existed or not and who went there. My minister,
a wonderful, warm man named Gary, told me Hell didn't exist
and was simply a concept used to control people through
guilt and fear, which were not the ways of Christ. He also
said that the idea of "sin" was also a tool concocted
largely to benefit whoever thought they were "moral"
and to dominate other people. This was not a Christian thing
to do and we should be more accepting of others and realize
that everyone sins and we are all trying as hard as we can.
Thus
even though I never really believed in Christian doctrine,
at least in that church, I thought there was a very good
attitude that was comforting instead of being about Fire
and Brimstone.
|
|
Charapa

|
Sigh...
if only all Christians were like that... |
| Jess

|
If
only! sounds like you went to a very progressive and liberal
church, Wendy! |
|
Angelo

|
What
of the Roman Catholic Church? (Definitely it is not
my church!) Ranting and raving against gay couples, very rarely
condemning pedophile priests or the abominable sacrilege of
suicide mass murders perpetrated by the mindless followers
of monsters like Bin Laden or Yassin! |
| Dreaming
Dervish

|
It
has been my blessing to attend the death of a dear friend.
If you have been there too, then you have also witnessed the
astonishing "leaving" of what some call the soul...
the departure of the energy, which leaves only a shell, a
costume of flesh and bone.
Some interesting history about death and
"passing over" can be found in the ancient texts
of: Tibetan Buddhism, the Tibetan Book of the Dead;
and there is also, the Egyptian Book of the Dead;
the Hindu's and Shavite's, have wonderful stories of the
great dark Lord of death, Yama. Native American and Aboriginal
tribes also honor the time of transition in magnificent
ways.
It seems like all the Spiritual Paths of
this world, have quite similar tales about death, if one
takes the time to sift through the dogma, the theme remains;
honor others, honor yourself, be kind, always, seek the
light!
Now, I figure there must be some reason
all these notions came about and have had power for so long.
In the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna says:
As
one throws away an old worn-out cloth, in the same manner,
one has to leave this body and take on a new one.
Books
about Death:
Graceful
Exits: Tales About the Deaths of Tibetan, Zen, & Hindu
Masters
Compiled by Sushila Blackman
Does
Death Really Exist
by Sw. Muktananda
|
|